Tellus, 46A, 512-528
On the Prediction of ENSO: a Study with a Low-order Markov Model
Yan Xue, Mark A. Cane, Stephen E. Zebiak and M. B. Blumenthal
Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, Columbia University, Palisades, New York
Keywords: ENSO, Markov model
Summary
A linear model best fit to the Zebiak and Cane (1987) ENSO forecast
model (ZC) is used to study the model's prediction skill. Multivariate
empirical orthogonal functions (MEOFs) obtained from the sea surface
temperature anomaly, sea level and wind stress anomaly fields in a
suite of 3-year forecast runs of ZC starting from the monthly initial
conditions in the period January 1970 to December 1991, are used to
construct a series of seasonally varying linear Markov models. It is
found that the model with 18 MEOFs fits the original nonlinear model
reasonably well and has comparable or better forecast
skill. Assimilating the observed SST into the initial conditions
further improves forecast skill at short lead times ( < 9 months). The
transient initial error growth in the model's prediction is
attributed to the non-self-adjoint property as in Farrell and
Blumenthal. Initial error grows fastest starting from spring and
slowest starting from late summer and is sensitive to the initial
error structures. Two singular vectors (SVs) of the linear evolution
operator have significant transient growth dominating the total
error growth. Since the optimal perturbation (fastest SV) has mostly
high MEOF components, the error growth tends to be larger when there
are more high mode components in the initial error fields. This result
suggests a way to filter the initial condition fields: the MEOFs
higher than the 18th in the initial fields are mostly noise and
removing them improves prediction skill. The forecasts starting from
late summer have the best predictability because the fastest growth
season (summer) is just avoided. The well known, very rapid decline in
forecast skill in the boreal spring (the "spring barrier") is here
attributed to the smallness of the signal to forecast: the standard
deviation of the NINO3 SST anomaly is smallest in spring.